Netflix Faces Subscriber Exodus Over Meghan Markle’s New ‘Tone Deaf’ Show
ENTERTAINMENT

Netflix Faces Subscriber Exodus Over Meghan Markle’s New ‘Tone Deaf’ Show

Netflix’s latest holiday special, With Love, Meghan: Holiday Celebration, has stirred up quite a reaction. Set to premiere on December...

By Max Pierson November 18, 2025 7 min read
Daily Express – X

Netflix’s latest holiday special, With Love, Meghan: Holiday Celebration, has stirred up quite a reaction. Set to premiere on December 3, 2025, the announcement has sparked a wave of mixed responses on social media.

While some fans express excitement, others are vocal in their criticism, questioning the programming choice. This move comes as Netflix continues to invest heavily in celebrity-driven content amid a fiercely competitive holiday streaming season.

But what exactly is behind the controversy, and how will it impact Netflix’s holiday season lineup? Keep reading to find out.

Social Media Response

media social media apps social network facebook symbols digital twitter network social networking icon communication www internet networking button social social media social media social media social media social media
Photo by Pixelkult on Pixabay


Following Netflix’s November announcement of “With Love, Meghan: Holiday Celebration,” social media platforms, including X, generated mixed reactions. According to Royal Insider’s November 12 coverage, some users posted cancellation statements, with at least one user writing, “Cancelled my subscription.”

Other X users expressed skepticism or intent to avoid the special. However, Netflix has not confirmed whether these social media comments represent actual subscription cancellations or provided any data quantifying an exodus.

The platform simultaneously received supportive comments from other viewers expressing enthusiasm for the special.

Netflix’s Content Strategy

flat screen television displaying Netflix logo
Photo by Thibault Penin on Unsplash


Netflix continues investing in high-profile celebrity projects as part of its diverse programming portfolio. The platform has greenlit celebrity-driven specials alongside other content categories.

Recent subscriber metrics show that Netflix grew revenue by 17% in Q3 2025, although the company stopped reporting quarterly subscriber numbers in early 2025, making real-time audience response assessment more difficult.​

Online Sentiment and Commentary

Imported image
X – WWD


Discussions about Meghan Markle’s special gained attention on X, where users posted both critical and supportive comments. Social media remains a platform where viewers publicly share their opinions about streaming content.

The range of reactions reflects diverse audience preferences regarding celebrity-focused programming and Netflix’s content allocation decisions.​

Special Production Details

Imported image
X – Kazinform


“With Love, Meghan: Holiday Celebration” is produced by Archewell Productions and filmed in Montecito, California, the affluent coastal community where Meghan Markle and Prince Harry reside.

The special features gift wrapping, holiday feasts, table settings, and celebrity guests. Netflix originally announced the title as “With Love, Meghan: Holiday Celebration,” premiering on December 3.​

Montecito Context

Imported image
X – montecito royals


The special’s filming location brings focus to Montecito, where Meghan and Harry purchased their nine-bedroom estate in June 2020 for approximately $14.7 million.

Property records indicate that the home’s estimated value has appreciated significantly to approximately $29-30 million, reflecting the broader growth of the California real estate market. The location has become increasingly recognized as a celebrity residential destination.​

Meghan’s Gift-Wrapping Background and Holiday Special Content

Imported image
X – Complex Pop Culture


Meghan Markle previously taught calligraphy, gift-wrapping, and book-binding at Paper Source’s Beverly Hills location from 2004 to 2005 while pursuing her acting career.

She has referenced this experience in discussing the upcoming special, noting it features “lots of gift wrapping techniques.”

The holiday special also showcases table settings, holiday feasts, and celebrity guests. This personal connection to gift-wrapping brings practical knowledge to the special’s content creation.

December 2025 Streaming Competition

Imported image
X – The Calvin Coolidge Project


Netflix’s December 2025 lineup features multiple holiday releases, including “With Love, Meghan.” Other streaming platforms, including Disney+, Amazon Prime Video, and traditional broadcasters, are releasing competing holiday programming.

Netflix’s December schedule features diverse content, including “Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery,” “Stranger Things” season 5 finale, and additional original holiday specials.​

Broader Streaming Industry Context

person holding remote pointing at TV
Photo by freestocks on Unsplash


The special represents ongoing industry trends in entertainment production and celebrity partnerships. Streaming platforms continue to balance celebrity-driven content with diverse programming to appeal to global audiences.

Holiday specials remain competitive programming categories as platforms compete for subscriber engagement during peak viewing seasons.​

Archewell Productions’ Role

Imported image
X – Royal News Network


Archewell Productions, co-founded by Meghan Markle and Prince Harry, produced the special as part of its ongoing relationship with Netflix. The production company has collaborated with Netflix on multiple projects.

The partnership between Archewell and Netflix reflects the broader trend of production companies partnering with streaming platforms.​

Prior Netflix Series Performance

Imported image
X – Royal News Network


Meghan Markle’s previous Netflix series, “With Love, Meghan,” which premiered in March 2025, achieved modest viewership. The show ranked #383 on Netflix’s rankings with 5.3 million views during the first half of 2025.

Season 2, released in August 2025, failed to achieve top rankings and received critical reviews that noted its underperformance. The new holiday special represents the production team’s continued work with Netflix.​

Industry Analysis and Commentary

Imported image
X – Daily Express


Industry analysts continue to examine the content decisions and audience reception patterns of streaming platforms. Commentary focuses on whether celebrity-driven specials resonate with diverse global audiences.

Some analysts question the return on investment for celebrity partnerships, while others note that holiday programming has traditionally attracted dedicated audience segments, regardless of broader critical reception.​

Netflix’s Marketing Approach

Imported image
X – House and Garden Magazine


Netflix includes “With Love, Meghan: Holiday Celebration” in its December 2025 promotional calendar alongside other major releases.

The company’s marketing strategy balances multiple competing titles across diverse genres and audience demographics.

Netflix’s approach reflects broader platform strategies of promoting diverse content simultaneously to reach varied subscriber interests.​

Streaming Market Dynamics

netflix smartphone display telephone mobile phone digital video netflix netflix netflix netflix netflix
Photo by napoleonschwan on Pixabay


Holiday specials remain a significant programming category within competitive streaming markets. Success varies based on audience demographics, critical reception, and competitive timing.

Multiple platforms release similar content simultaneously, requiring platforms to differentiate through marketing and audience targeting strategies.

Industry observers continue monitoring whether pre-release social media sentiment correlates with actual viewership.​

What’s Ahead for Netflix and Archewell?

person using silver and black laptop computer
Photo by charlesdeluvio on Unsplash


Netflix’s December 2025 schedule moves forward with planned releases, including “With Love, Meghan: Holiday Celebration.”

The platform continues its content strategy of diversifying programming while maintaining celebrity partnerships.

Both Netflix and Archewell Productions will monitor audience response as the December 3 premiere approaches.​

Celebrity Content Reception Trends

Imported image
X – Film Updates


Celebrity-driven entertainment continues to generate varied audience responses across global markets. Commentary reflects ongoing cultural conversations about celebrity influence, lifestyle content, and streaming platform priorities.

Different demographic groups express differing preferences regarding celebrity-focused programming and entertainment consumption patterns.​

Global Streaming Landscape

white and black concrete building during night time
Photo by Venti Views on Unsplash


Netflix serves over 283 million global subscribers across diverse international markets. Holiday programming caters to audiences with diverse cultural preferences and varying entertainment expectations.

The regional response to celebrity content varies significantly based on market-specific factors, cultural contexts, and audience demographics across different geographic regions.​

Production Partnership Considerations

laptop netflix entertainment technology movies watch leisure screen shows fun netflix netflix netflix netflix netflix
Photo by yousafbhutta on Pixabay


Netflix’s collaboration with Archewell Productions reflects standard industry practices for content development and distribution.

Production partnerships involve contractual arrangements governing creative control, promotional responsibilities, and revenue sharing.

The special represents one project within broader production relationships between streaming platforms and independent production companies.​

Audience Demographics and Preferences

black flat screen tv turned on displaying 11
Photo by Mollie Sivaram on Unsplash


Netflix’s subscriber base represents diverse audiences with varying preferences for programming categories. Holiday specials appeal to different demographic segments, including families, lifestyle enthusiasts, and casual viewers.

Audience reception varies significantly based on age, geographic location, cultural background, and individual entertainment preferences.​

Evolving Streaming Content Landscape

A steaming mug on a table in front of a TV displaying Netflix creating a cozy indoor atmosphere
Photo by John-Mark Smith on Pexels


Netflix continues navigating competitive streaming markets by balancing celebrity partnerships, diverse programming, and subscriber engagement strategies.

The platform’s approach reflects industry-wide challenges of maintaining audience interest amid content proliferation.

“With Love, Meghan: Holiday Celebration” represents one data point within Netflix’s broader 2025 content strategy and long-term platform positioning.​